Tumblr SEO Revisited: an inside look into Tumblr link value

One of our most popular blog posts to date is our 3 part Tumblr SEO series we did last year. We’ve had thousands of visitors to that page, dozens of emails and hundreds of social interactions as a result of that series. But a few things have changed in the last year or so and we’d like to cover them.

It started off when I read a question on Reddit /r/SEO and it got me thinking…

The question is as follows:

I’ve been reading that Tumblr links are “do follow” and can offer a lot of SEO value. I am a little confused though. If the original blog domain was blog.tumblr.com, but you purchase a custom domain making it blog.mywebsite.com, will any links reblogged through Tumblr affect my actual website or just the Tumblr?

Clarifying the Tumblr Do-follow Question

First off, Tumblr is a blogging platform just like WordPress or Blogger. That is, it is not in the same category as Facebook or Twitter which are social networks.

If Facebook, Twitter or Google+ decides to no-follow all of their links, that is entirely up to them. On a blogging platform such as Tumblr, the hyperlink attribute is entirely up to the owner of the blog. Some Tumblr themes no-follow their links, others keep them as do-follow, and some of them mix and match. Other times Tumblr webmasters choose to no-follow certain links but leave the rest do-follow.

There is one exception to that rule. Tumblr does control some of the linking that happens within the framework. For instance anytime you reblog something at the bottom of the post it lists who reblogged it. Those links by default are all no-follow (more on that later.)

tumblr ahref

What exactly is Tumblr reblogging from an SEO standpoint?

By reblogging a Tumblr post, you are essentially re-sharing that post on your own Tumblr site. The only difference between a regular post and one that is reblogged is the one that is reblogged cites a reference in the form of a link back to the original account, the date, and any hashtags that went along with it.

Reblogging can be a very powerful tool on Tumblr. We have one post on Tumblr from our Tumblr SEO series that has been reblogged, linked to, and liked hundreds of times. As a result of this it brings us tons of traffic and the Tumblr post itself is ranked on the first page for a number of search terms.

To answer the question: will any links reblogged through Tumblr affect my actual website or just the Tumblr.

In my opinion, yes. This used to be extremely easy to game. Back in the day, you could use blackhat methods to get reblogs for your Tumblr posts. Each time you got a reblog it would create a do-follow link from the profile and drive link juice back to the post. With little effort, you could get these bad boys ranking for solid keywords on their own.

Rebloggging can still have an impact on SEO as a side-effect. Tumblr has its own internal algorithm and getting lots of reblogs can get your Tumblr post ranked higher within Tumblr’s own search results.

If you were Googlebot, would you treat these 3 situations the same?

In my opinion, these 3 scenarios would be treated extremely different. The question “do Tumblr links matter” is not black and white. As with any website or page on the web, all websites have their own page authority and domain authority. Take a look at these 2 Tumblr blogs, my personal one that I rarely use, and our company Tumblr that gets a lot of attention.

open site explorer tumblr domain authority

All Tumblr’s have the same domain authority, but need to earn their own page authority.

As you can see, all Tumblr blogs have an extremely high domain authority. But that doesn’t really matter when it comes to link juice. Page authority is the magic number here. Sites on *.wordpress.com are the same way. Extremely high domain authority, but you have to earn your page authority.

White Men Wearing Google Glass, a very popular Tumblr got so much attention within just a few weeks that its PA shot up to a 70 at one point, it is currently a 62.

In essence, there is no cheating anymore. You can game the system for a little while, but eventually you’ll get hammered into submission by the great gods of Google.

Custom Tumblr Domains

This is a very tricky topic. Webmasters can change their URL from whatever.Tumblr.com to example.com (or whatever.example.com) for a variety of reasons.

A custom Tumblr domain will retain and possess its own domain authority and page authority, unlike normal Tumblr’s that reside on the tumblr.com domain.

If a visits the Tumblr URL they will be automatically redirected to their custom domain.

Webmasters and business owners can choose to have a custom Tumblr domain for a number of different reasons. Sometimes a Tumblr starts out as a fun little blog, and turns into a major project.

I hope some of this answered your questions, let me know if you have any more!

Patrick Coombe
Patrick Coombe is the founder and CEO of Elite Strategies Llc. Patrick takes a hands on approach to managing Elite Strategies and loves to get involved with technical projects relating to clients inbound marketing needs.
Patrick Coombe
Patrick Coombe
  5 COMMENTS
Blog SEO Tumblr
  • Written by: Madhushalini

    I’ve a question: Outbound links to authority sites should be no-follow or do-follow? Please reply asap.

    • Written by: Patrick Coombe

      I’d definitely keep them do-follow, it won’t hurt. Interesting you say that, I actually wrote a post a while ago about OBL’s in regards to SEO.

      http://www.elite-strategies.com/myth-high-obls-bad-seo-pagerank/

      Only exception is if I have a ton of links or someone asks for the link, I’ll no-follow it!

      Thanks again for stopping by 🙂

  • Written by: Fredrik

    What is a “good” PA for a normal Tumblr account? Is there a difference between Tumblr pages and WordPress for example?

    • Written by: Patrick Coombe

      Hey Fredrik – thanks for coming by. I’d say once you start getting into 30-40PA you start getting into some good numbers. 50+ is the big boys. Our Tumblr:

      http://elitestrategies.tumblr.com is a PA 42 for instance, and we’ve been actively working on this for 3-4 years now.

      Tumblr.com pages and WordPress.com are basically set up the same way. The domain authority is calculated off the main domain, and the page authority is calculated based on the sub-domain.

  • Written by: Patrick Coombe

    First of all thank you General Thumbs up for coming by. I did have to edit your post because there was a bunch of gibberish characters in the middle of your post for some reason. As per your comment, no one really knows the answer except Google. Just remember Tumblr custom domains are basically the same, except they have their own domain authority.

  • Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    Contact Info

    900 Linton Blvd, Suite 104
    Delray Beach, FL 33444

    Phone: 561-526-8457
    Toll Free: 855-353-8730
    E-mail: info@elite-strategies.com
    Fax: 561-526-8707